Discussion
A page with a busy Talk tab: a proposal to archive stale pages, and plenty of opinions about it.
Discussion
A proposal to archive stale pages, put up for comment.
This page is here for its Talk tab
The proposal is fictional. What it is for is the discussion underneath it — several people,
threads of replies, mentions and a couple of guests — so the comments view has something to draw.
Summary
Move every page that nobody has edited in two years into an /archive folder, leave a
redirection at its old path, and show a banner on it saying it may be out of date.
Motivation
- Search results are crowded with pages describing systems we retired
- Nobody knows which pages are still true, so nobody trusts any of them
- New starters read the stale ones first, because the stale ones are the ones with the good titles
What would happen
- A nightly job lists pages whose last edit is older than the threshold
- Each owner gets two weeks’ notice, and can mark a page evergreen to keep it where it is
- Whatever is left is moved, with a redirection left behind
Open questions
- Is two years the right threshold, or should it differ per section?
- Who owns a page whose author has left?
- Should archived pages stay searchable?